Why you rank near your address and fade a few miles out
Distance counts for the most close to home. Within a mile or two of your shop, Google will often show you even with a thin profile. Farther out you're up against businesses that sit closer to the searcher, and only stronger relevance and prominence keep you in the top three.
A map ranking scan shows where that happens. We run your main search from a grid of points across your service area, say Southside, the Beaches, and Orange Park, and record your position at each one. The numbers usually look good around your shop and get worse toward the edges. Run the same scan a month later and you can see exactly which spots moved.